NUMBERED FANDOMS:
Jack Speer gave us an unparalleled fanhistorical tool when he
articulated his essential theory of Numbered Fandoms in "Up to
Now" at the end of the 1930's, which he revised for the first
Fancyclopedia (1944). This gave us an outline of the first
three numbered fandoms and their interregna or "transitions".
Bob Silverberg was next, updating the theory as far as Sixth
Fandom in his column in QUANDRY in 1952.
Dick Eney, in FanCy II, updated the notions to 1959
sensibilities.
There have been a number of articles over the years by Ted
White, rich brown and Arnie Katz, among others, attempting to
update and/or refine upon these originals. Even those
participants who've likened it to medieval disputes over how
many angels can dance on the head of a pin have nonetheless
hauled it out, from time to time, dusted it off and discussed
it all yet again.
This, consequently, despite its length, is but the briefest
kind of thumb-nail sketch.
A numbered fandom is essentially a fannish era with distinct
characteristics and a strong identifiable focus. In earlier
expositions of the theory, this would usually be exemplified by
a particular fanzine; as a result, sometime in the '60s, the
notion took hold that each numbered fandom had its own "focal
point" fanzine which exemplified that fandom-- to such an
extent that being on the fringes of fandom was in part defined
by not being a recipient of the zine. Speer identified
specific fanzines with First and Third Fandoms, Silverbob did
the same for Fifth and Sixth Fandoms. Eney did not identify
any specific fanzine title in tacking on what he identified as
the "false" Seventh (the Sixth Transition) and a later period
as the real Seventh Fandom.
However, as the focal-point idea has taken hold, the gaps
have been filled.
A transition or interregnum is a period when a given
numbered fandom begins to come apart for one reason or another
and fandom finds itself looking for a new focus or focal point.
Eofandom: 1930-33. In his first exposition of the notion,
Speer apparently started First Fandom a bit on the late side;
rather than back up and start all over, he simply named the
preceding period (in which fandom was a star just beginning to
coalesce anyway) "Eofandom". Keep in mind that the first all-
stf prozine had been published only four years prior to the
beginning of this period, and it took a while for fans to take
advantage of the fact that it printed complete addresses in its
lettercolumns, so they could contact other enthusiasts nearby
and bein to correspond with those who lived far away. The
first fanzine, THE COMET, was published during this period;
letterhacking was a major activity. Strange new air-breathing
lifeforms were said to have crawled off the bottom of the sea
and up onto the land where they immediately began to suck life
from the varied plants abounding there.
First Fandom: 1933-36. The emphasis was on serious science
and serious discussion of science fiction, news of what was
forthcoming in the scientific world as well as sf books and
prozines, interviews with authors and the like. The focal
point fanzine was FANTASY MAGAZINE--it had the clear advantage
in being a printed journal among a lot of hectographed
publications.
First Interregnum: late 1936 - Oct. 1937. FANTASY MAGAZINE
began its decline, Gernbackian "ideal" (that reading sf should
lead to an interest, and possibly a career, in science) was
dumped in favor of considering sf for its own sake or, as in
some quarters, a turn away from the professional field to begin
a more intense consideration of individual fan personalities.
Second Fandom: Oct. 1937 - Oct. 1938. The increasing
emphasis on fan personalities and de-emphasis of sf-related
talk brought discussions of politics to the fore, and as a
rather dominant group included a bunch of young Communists
(John Michel, Donald A. Wollheim, whom their enemies _and_
followers called variously "Michelists," "Willheimists" and
"Futurians"), this led to unparalleled feuding until virtually
all of fandom was effectively at war. No focal point fanzine
was named for this era by Speer, Silverberg or Eney; I have
heard Olin F. Wiggins' SCIENCE FICTION FAN suggested, but I am
not able to verify how many, _if_ any, of its issues may have been published
during this 13-month period. Then too, as
Wiggins lived in Denver, it's hard to see how he or his fanzine
could have been "central" to a fandom that was so patently
focused on the doings of the New York Futurians. Perhaps it
was confused with Futurian Dick Wilson's SCIENCE FICTION NEWS
LETTER, which was published on a frequent basis at or near the right period.
Second Transition: From the 1938 conference in Philadelphia
through the second Worldcon in Chicago in 1940. The Barbarian
Invasion, a heavy influx of new fans, led to the emergence of
New Fandom and a reemphasis on heavy interest in sf. Feuding
continued to manifest itself, taking on such forms as the
Exclusion Act at the 1939 New York (World) convention which
barred a number of Michelists from attending.
Third Fandom: Sept. 1940 - early 1944. The focal point
fanzine of third fandom was Harry Warner Jr.'s SPACEWAYS. You
won't discover this from reading his books of fanhistory--
_All Our Yesterdays_ and _A Wealth of Fable_--or from the
collected "All Our Yesterdays" columns he used to write,
because Harry doesn't subscribe to the notion of numbered
fandoms or focal point fanzines. (Nonetheless, "all" of his
fanhistorical works are highly recommended.) But SPACEWAYS was
both frequent enough and influential enough, and he had an
advantage not dissimilar from that which had been held by
FANTASY MAGAZINE; namely, in Harry's case, he had found a real
bargain in a used mimeograph while most of his contemporaries
were still using hectographs. The hectograph, being a carbon
process, has a limit on legible copies that effectively limits
publication to about 50 and surely no more than 100 readable
copies and is a painstaking one-page-at-a-time process to boot;
the practical limit on mimeography, which Warner never had to
come near, is in the tens of thousands. This let Warner set
the example by simply not allowing people to feud in his
fanzine. There was much talk of fandom "maturing" as warring
factions mended bridges; the FAPA Brain Trust came into being,
as did the more intellectual Vanguard Amateur Press
Association, and some effort was being made to establish a
national fan organization.
Third Interregnum: Early to late 1944. Wartime shortages,
older fans entering the war effort, thinning of the blood of
the FAPA Brain Trust, power struggles in VAPA and an influx of
new blood brought an end to Third Fandom and produced this
"little" transition.
Fourth Fandom: Late 1944 - Philcon I (1947). Silverberg and
Eney agree that Fourth Fandom took place mostly in the long
letter columns published in minuscule type in the back pages of
TWS, SS and PLANET STORIES--due partly to a new influx of fans
and wartime paper shortages that affected fan publishing. For
those who need a fanzine focal point, Joe Kennedy's VAMPIRE has
been suggested; it was clearly the "place to be" and, although
a quarterly, it published yearbooks in 1944 and 1945 that doled
out the most meaningful egoboo during the period--plus, of
course, Kennedy was among the more active fans in those letter
columns. There was considerable ill-feeling expressed against
the Shaver Mystery by fans of this period, but fandom never got
organized or effective enough to Force The Issue; Forry
Ackerman urged fans to boycott AMAZING but was purchasing three
copies of each issue to keep his collection complete, and
editor Ray Palmer recognized the expediency of placating fandom
and managed for the most part to do so by instituting a column
of fan news and fanzine reviews in AMAZING called "The Club
House" written by Rog Phillips.
Although there's no Fourth Interregnum listed, it's worth
noting that by the time of the Pacificon in 1945--the first
world convention since the 1941 Denvention--Laney's ACOLYTE and
the Burbee-edited SHANGRI-L'AFFAIRS topped the fanzine polls.
The Insurgency had not yet come to a boil but everything it
would need to do so was already in place.
Fifth Fandom: 1947 PhilCon I - mid-1950. Laney stopped
publishing ACOLYTE, the LASFS relieved Charles Burbee of his
editorial duties on SHANGRI-L'AFFAIRS (they didn't like the
fact that he poked fun at their more sober-sided members, or
that he would publish "outside" material rather than put off
deadlines when LASFS members failed to come up with promised
material on time). They both "retired" to FAPA, where they
began to refine their insurgency in WILD HAIR and numerous
one-shots—-Laney with his memoirs (which he pronounced ME-
moirs), "Ah, Sweet Idiocy," Burbee with a series of satires
that made his previous editorials seem mild. In the vacuum
created in general fanzine fandom, Art Rapp's SPACEWARP became
the focal point for Fifth Fandom; it had some serious material,
namely Redd Boggs' "File 13" column, but it was mixed with
Rapp's humorous stories of Morgan Botts, the stf-fan inventor,
and his creation (with Outlanders Ed Cox and Rick Sneary) of
the fannish and funloving religion revolving around the worship
of Roscoe, the mighty beaver. When Rapp reentered the Army as
a bomb went off on his front lawn and the Korean Conflict was
getting started, he more or less formally aligned himself with
the insurgents by having Burbee and Laney publish the 49th and
50th issues of SPACEWARP. Rapp was also instrumental in the
formation of FAPA's first successful long-time rival apa, the
Spectator Amateur Press Society, or SAPS. (Both FAPA and SAPS
are still going concerns.)
If there was an interregnum between Fifth and Sixth, it had
to be a brief one, since in early '51 SPACEWARP became a
quarterly SAPSzine with limited general circulation while a
relative newcomer named newcomer named Lee Hoffman started
publishing a monthly fanzine called QUANDRY.
Sixth Fandom: Early 1951 through (at least) May 1953. Lee
Hoffman modestly began publishing QUANDRY (a mispelling of
"quandary"); after just a few months, she picked up a column by
Fourth Fandom's Joe Kennedy, Redd Boggs' SPACEWARP column "File
13" and a brilliant new fan columnist from Belfast, North
Ireland named Walter A. Willis who wrote "The Harp That Once Or
Twice". The rest, as they say in the cliches, is History.
Early on, Q inspired or was inspired by other relatively new
fanzines like Willis's SLANT, Shelby Vick's CONFUSION, Max
Keasler's FAN VARIETY/OPUS; . A serious sf "boom" was under
way, with dozens of magazine titles on the stands, so while sf
was sometimes discussed, the emphasis during Sixth Fandom was
on fans, fandom, humor, and mutual appreciation of things like
Walt Kelley's Pogo, Roger Price's philosophy of "avoidism" and
Stephen Potter's oneupsmanship. Willis and Bob Shaw wrote and
publish the Pilgrim's Progress of trufandom, THE ENCHANTED
DUPLICATOR. The humor of Sixth Fandom was gentler (or more
inclusive) than the satires of Burbee and Laney, and so was
known as Serious Constructive Insurgentism. The first
successful fund to bring a fan from overseas to attend a US
convention brought Willis to the Chicon; he produced two
con reports, a fictional one written before the event ("Willis
Discovers America"), published in fanzines that supported the
Fund, and a long over-the-shoulder account that was first
serialized in his "Harp" column and was eventually published as
"The Harp Stateside."
Seventh Transition: May 1953 - ? Here's where things start
to get sticky as different theories begin to hop about. In the
Hollowe'en '52 issue of QUANDRY, Bob Silverberg had devoted his
column to updating Jack Speer's numbered fandoms theory. Bob's
piece was flawed in two important ways. First, he speculated
that Sixth Fandom (QUANDRY et al.) was beginning to collapse—-
Max Keasler and ShelVy had gafiated, LeeH was talking of
cutting back the pace--and so maybe (he said) Sixth was on the
way out and a group of promising new fans would become Seventh
Fandom. Second, for whatever reason, he never mentioned the
concept of transitions; possibly Speer didn't get around to
putting them in until his FANCYCLOPEDIA and Bob was working
from the earlier piece. Whatever the reason, any relatively
new fans reading Silverberg's column might reasonably come
away beleiving that whenever a numbered fandom died, another
group was inevitably to be found standing on the sidelines
waiting to pick up the banner. The upshot of it all was that
when, several months later, the final Q showed up with black
borders around the cover, announcing its own demise, the
Silverberg piece became both prophecy and challenge. Harlan
Ellison called a group of young fans together in his apartment
in Cleveland and they picked up the challenge: They went on to
MidWestCon to announced that "7th fandom" had arrived. This
subsequently become known as "False Seventh Fandom" or even the
Sixth Transition, Harlan and his friends were villified--not by
anyone in Sixth Fandom that I'm aware of, more like people who
were Harlan's contemporaries who felt they'd been left out and
didn't have sense enough to simply proclaim themselves part of
it. Harlan left fandom after declaring that 7th Fandn had been
"kneed in the groin" by mad dogs, which many people found funny
because of its anatomic impossibility. Out of spite, no doubt,
Harlan went on to become perhaps the finest writer ever to come
out of science fiction. Other theorists have come along to say
that the false 7th Fandom was the Sixth Interegnum, and then
that the real Seventh Fandom didn't happen until perhaps early
1956, when FANAC got started. Other theorists say Seventh
Fandom's focal point was Joel Nydahl's VEGA, and it "handed
off" the focalpointhood to the first incarnation of Dick Geis's
PSYCHOTIC. Ted White theorized that Sixth Fandom "didn't" end
with Q-—Q handed off to VEGA which handed off to PSY. So the
"real" Seventh Fandom could be Harlan & friends, it could start
with VEGA, it could start with SFR, or it could start with
FANAC. Putting it yet another way, FANAC could be the focal
point of Seventh, Eighth, Ninth Fandom or even 10th Fandom.
The point is this: Up to Sixth Fandom, the tool works as a
kind of fan historical shorthand; mention any of the first six
"fandoms" and most fans conversant with the general theory will
have a pretty good idea of what you mean. But once Seventh
Fandom is brought in, you have to explain which Seventh Fandom
you mean--at which point it ceases to be shorthand. (rb)
|